Read Our Reviews from Top Rated Dealer In Muncie, IN

Polish Kings (LLC)

05/06/2026

5.00

Buying my new Tesla Model 3 was an amazing experience from start to finish. Kyler was an outstanding salesman who made the process smooth, professional, and pressure free. He answered every question I had, kept great communication with a nice smile, and genuinely made me feel excited about the purchase.Matt in finance was equally great to work with. He explained everything clearly, made the paperwork process easy to understand, and helped everything move quickly and efficiently without stress.And a huge thank you to Todd, the owner, for creating such a welcoming and professional environment. You can tell the dealership truly cares about customer experience and treating people the right way.Last but not least Ben, such a gentleman, greeted me with a smile & an umbrella!Overall, this was hands down one of the best car buying experiences I’ve had. Highly recommend working with Kyler, Matt, Todd & Ben if you’re looking for a vehicle.

Tyler Titamer

04/21/2026

5.00

Seen a truck I that caught my eye, was extremely interested in test driving it and brining it home. Kyler was incredibly easy to work with as well as the owner Todd. Exceed my expectations with the ideal price I was wanted to be at. Easy deal and smooth transaction. Would highly recommend giving them an opportunity for anyone in the market looking for a newer used car. Lots of quality options on their lot and quality people to help you out. Tell Kyler I sent you!

Sheila Hayden

04/03/2026

5.00

Looking at cars with my daughter, I was truly blessed by the friendliness, guidance and willingness to work with her bank. Would definitely recommend this place!!

Ruth Borum

03/27/2026

5.00

Greatest service ever . Ask for Dallas

Taylor Smith

03/23/2026

5.00

I had an amazing experience at Todd castor cars. My fiancé got a car from them about 5 months ago and when my old car broke down, we knew exactly where to go. They were extremely welcoming, kind, and helpful. They even remembered my fiancé. Everyone there treats you like family. I would recommend todd castor cars to anyone looking for a new or used car. Dallas was specifically an amazing salesman and is so helpful and happy to answer any questions. Thank you Dallas, Matt, and everyone at Todd Castor cars! Truly the best!

Champ B

03/23/2026

5.00

I recently purchased Tesla Y from this dealership and had a great experience from start to finish. The team was knowledgeable, transparent, and never made me feel pressured at any point. They answered all my questions clearly, especially regarding the vehicle condition and pricing. The process was smooth and efficient, and everything was exactly as promised.I’m very happy with my purchase and would definitely recommend this dealership to anyone looking for a quality vehicle.Specially thanks to kyler and matt.

SHELIA BERRY

03/06/2026

5.00

Allison Carty

02/15/2026

5.00

Great experience at Todd Castor Cars! Ben was a kind, straightforward, professional salesman. Matt made the financial part of the process simple and personable. Highly recommend this dealership! It was the most fun I think I'll ever have buying a car!

Ara Weir

02/10/2026

5.00

Vin Thoma

02/05/2026

5.00

I had an amazing experience at Todd Castor Cars, and I can’t recommend them enough. Kyler went above and beyond throughout the entire process, knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely looking out for my best interest. He made buying a car feel easy and stress-free, which is rare. Huge shoutout as well to Ben, who was great to work with, and Matt, who was extremely transparent and understanding. No pressure, no games, just honest communication and a smooth process from start to finish. These guys are true professionals who genuinely take pride in their craft. A great team up there in Muncie no question. If you’re in the market for a car and want to be treated right, I highly recommend going to Todd Castor Cars. Ask for Kyler. You won’t be disappointed! Kyler knows Cars💯